From Institutionalized Musicality to Idiosyncratic Musickership: Calling a Paradigm into Question

Onderzoeksoutput: ChapterAcademicpeer review


The EAS conference theme “Craftsmanship & Artistry” confers the image that general music education in 21st western century society moves from a work-based (cf. Small 1998: 2) towards a performance-based definition of music. An example is the work of the MayDay-Group, which formulates many of its seven ideals for general music education in terms of music making (Regelski e.a. 2009: xxxii).This centrality of musicianship is not straightforward. Music is not one but a set of activities (Clarke 2005: 204), and for many music is meaningful in daily life without performance being central. Based on my own research of a varied selection of individuals narrating the importance of music in their lives, this article argues that craftsmanship and artistry are only two of many more ways of describing what music essentially “is”.We must take Cavicchi’s (2009) thesis on the bifurcation of everyday and institutionalized musicality and the resulting “irrelevance of music education” seriously. Musicianship can’t be positioned a-priori at the core of music education; its core must be located on the basis of research into what music means in the actual lives of actual people. This leads towards a more learner-centered approach to general music education in which each learner’s idio-syncratic “musicker-ship” is the starting point.
Originele taal-2English
TitelEuropean perspectives on music education
RedacteurenAdri de Vugt, Isolde Malmberg
Plaats van productieRum bei Innsbruck
ISBN van geprinte versie9783850619813
StatusPublished - 2013


  • muziekonderwijs
  • idiocultural music education

Vingerafdruk Duik in de onderzoeksthema's van 'From Institutionalized Musicality to Idiosyncratic Musickership: Calling a Paradigm into Question'. Samen vormen ze een unieke vingerafdruk.

Citeer dit