The advantages of an ADHD classification from the perspective of teachers

Albert W. Wienen, Maruschka N. Sluiter, Ernst Thoutenhoofd, Peter de Jonge, Laura Batstra

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

In Western countries, the number of ADHD diagnoses and medical treatments of children has risen spectacularly over the last decennia, as has the amount of criticism about this trend. Various studies have shown that children receiving an ADHD classification often follow from initial signals that were raised in a school context. Hence, it becomes important to investigate precisely what advantages attach to ADHD classification in educational practice. In this qualitative study, 30 teachers were interviewed about their experiences and views of ADHD. The results suggest that a small number of interviewees sees no advantages to ADHD classification: the classification does not practically help them as teachers, they are familiar with the drawbacks of ADHD classification, and they take issue with the idea of labelling children. The greater number of interviewees, however, suggest ambivalence about ADHD classification: they are aware of its drawbacks while experiencing mainly advantages. According to the interviewees, ADHD classification explains undesirable behaviours and disappointing academic achievement. Classification thereby removes blame from pupils, parents and teachers, and so can be a starting point for productive agreement and collaboration. We will discuss the implications of these findings in the light of the concept of reification, child-centred problematisation and the development of more inclusive education.
Original languageEnglish
JournalEuropean journal of special needs education
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 26 Feb 2019
Externally publishedYes

Keywords

  • adhd
  • teachers

Cite this

@article{261e4270a5fa49c98abd31bbfd09102c,
title = "The advantages of an ADHD classification from the perspective of teachers",
abstract = "In Western countries, the number of ADHD diagnoses and medical treatments of children has risen spectacularly over the last decennia, as has the amount of criticism about this trend. Various studies have shown that children receiving an ADHD classification often follow from initial signals that were raised in a school context. Hence, it becomes important to investigate precisely what advantages attach to ADHD classification in educational practice. In this qualitative study, 30 teachers were interviewed about their experiences and views of ADHD. The results suggest that a small number of interviewees sees no advantages to ADHD classification: the classification does not practically help them as teachers, they are familiar with the drawbacks of ADHD classification, and they take issue with the idea of labelling children. The greater number of interviewees, however, suggest ambivalence about ADHD classification: they are aware of its drawbacks while experiencing mainly advantages. According to the interviewees, ADHD classification explains undesirable behaviours and disappointing academic achievement. Classification thereby removes blame from pupils, parents and teachers, and so can be a starting point for productive agreement and collaboration. We will discuss the implications of these findings in the light of the concept of reification, child-centred problematisation and the development of more inclusive education.",
keywords = "adhd, classificatie, docenten, adhd, teachers",
author = "Wienen, {Albert W.} and Sluiter, {Maruschka N.} and Ernst Thoutenhoofd and {de Jonge}, Peter and Laura Batstra",
year = "2019",
month = "2",
day = "26",
doi = "10.1080/08856257.2019.1580838",
language = "English",
journal = "European journal of special needs education",
issn = "0885-6257",
publisher = "Routledge",

}

The advantages of an ADHD classification from the perspective of teachers. / Wienen, Albert W.; Sluiter, Maruschka N.; Thoutenhoofd, Ernst; de Jonge, Peter; Batstra, Laura.

In: European journal of special needs education, 26.02.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The advantages of an ADHD classification from the perspective of teachers

AU - Wienen, Albert W.

AU - Sluiter, Maruschka N.

AU - Thoutenhoofd, Ernst

AU - de Jonge, Peter

AU - Batstra, Laura

PY - 2019/2/26

Y1 - 2019/2/26

N2 - In Western countries, the number of ADHD diagnoses and medical treatments of children has risen spectacularly over the last decennia, as has the amount of criticism about this trend. Various studies have shown that children receiving an ADHD classification often follow from initial signals that were raised in a school context. Hence, it becomes important to investigate precisely what advantages attach to ADHD classification in educational practice. In this qualitative study, 30 teachers were interviewed about their experiences and views of ADHD. The results suggest that a small number of interviewees sees no advantages to ADHD classification: the classification does not practically help them as teachers, they are familiar with the drawbacks of ADHD classification, and they take issue with the idea of labelling children. The greater number of interviewees, however, suggest ambivalence about ADHD classification: they are aware of its drawbacks while experiencing mainly advantages. According to the interviewees, ADHD classification explains undesirable behaviours and disappointing academic achievement. Classification thereby removes blame from pupils, parents and teachers, and so can be a starting point for productive agreement and collaboration. We will discuss the implications of these findings in the light of the concept of reification, child-centred problematisation and the development of more inclusive education.

AB - In Western countries, the number of ADHD diagnoses and medical treatments of children has risen spectacularly over the last decennia, as has the amount of criticism about this trend. Various studies have shown that children receiving an ADHD classification often follow from initial signals that were raised in a school context. Hence, it becomes important to investigate precisely what advantages attach to ADHD classification in educational practice. In this qualitative study, 30 teachers were interviewed about their experiences and views of ADHD. The results suggest that a small number of interviewees sees no advantages to ADHD classification: the classification does not practically help them as teachers, they are familiar with the drawbacks of ADHD classification, and they take issue with the idea of labelling children. The greater number of interviewees, however, suggest ambivalence about ADHD classification: they are aware of its drawbacks while experiencing mainly advantages. According to the interviewees, ADHD classification explains undesirable behaviours and disappointing academic achievement. Classification thereby removes blame from pupils, parents and teachers, and so can be a starting point for productive agreement and collaboration. We will discuss the implications of these findings in the light of the concept of reification, child-centred problematisation and the development of more inclusive education.

KW - adhd

KW - classificatie

KW - docenten

KW - adhd

KW - teachers

U2 - 10.1080/08856257.2019.1580838

DO - 10.1080/08856257.2019.1580838

M3 - Article

JO - European journal of special needs education

JF - European journal of special needs education

SN - 0885-6257

ER -