Research article – Optimisation of paediatrics computed radiographyfor full spine curvature measurements using a phantom: a pilot study

Seraphine de Haan, Cláudia Reis, Junior Ndlovu, Catarina Serrenho, Ifrah Akhtar, José Antonio Garcia, Daniël Linde, Martine Thorskog, Loris Franco, Peter Hogg

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingContribution to conference proceedingAcademicpeer-review

7 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Aim: Optimise a set of exposure factors, with the lowest effective dose, to delineate spinal curvature with the modified Cobb method in a full spine using computed radiography (CR) for a 5-year-old paediatric anthropomorphic phantom.
Methods: Images were acquired by varying a set of parameters: positions (antero-posterior (AP), posteroanterior (PA) and lateral), kilo-voltage peak (kVp) (66-90), source-to-image distance (SID) (150 to 200cm), broad focus and the use of a grid (grid in/out) to analyse the impact on E and image quality
(IQ). IQ was analysed applying two approaches: objective [contrast-to-noise-ratio/(CNR] and perceptual, using 5 observers. Monte-Carlo modelling was used for dose estimation. Cohen’s Kappa coefficient was used to calculate inter-observer-variability. The angle was measured using Cobb’s method on lateral
projections under different imaging conditions.
Results: PA promoted the lowest effective dose (0.013 mSv) compared to AP (0.048 mSv) and lateral (0.025 mSv). The exposure parameters that allowed lower dose were 200cm SID, 90 kVp, broad focus and grid out for paediatrics using an Agfa CR system. Thirty-seven images were assessed for IQ and
thirty-two were classified adequate. Cobb angle measurements varied between 16°±2.9 and 19.9°±0.9.
Conclusion: Cobb angle measurements can be performed using the lowest dose with a low contrast-tonoise ratio. The variation on measurements for this was ±2.9° and this is within the range of acceptable clinical error without impact on clinical diagnosis. Further work is recommended on improvement to
the sample size and a more robust perceptual IQ assessment protocol for observers.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationOPTIMAX 2014 – radiation dose and image quality optimisation in medical imaging
Place of PublicationLisbon, Portugal
Pages44-53
ISBN (Electronic) 9781907842603
Publication statusPublished - 2015
EventOPTIMAX 2014: radiation dose and image quality optimisation in medical imaging - Lisbon , Portugal
Duration: 1 Aug 201431 Aug 2014

Seminar

SeminarOPTIMAX 2014
CountryPortugal
CityLisbon
Period1/08/1431/08/14

Keywords

  • optimisation
  • spinal curvature measurements
  • effective dose
  • image quality
  • paediatrics
  • imaging phantom
  • computed radiography

Cite this

de Haan, S., Reis, C., Ndlovu, J., Serrenho, C., Akhtar, I., Garcia, J. A., ... Hogg, P. (2015). Research article – Optimisation of paediatrics computed radiographyfor full spine curvature measurements using a phantom: a pilot study. In OPTIMAX 2014 – radiation dose and image quality optimisation in medical imaging (pp. 44-53). Lisbon, Portugal.
de Haan, Seraphine ; Reis, Cláudia ; Ndlovu, Junior ; Serrenho, Catarina ; Akhtar, Ifrah ; Garcia, José Antonio ; Linde, Daniël ; Thorskog, Martine ; Franco, Loris ; Hogg, Peter. / Research article – Optimisation of paediatrics computed radiographyfor full spine curvature measurements using a phantom: a pilot study. OPTIMAX 2014 – radiation dose and image quality optimisation in medical imaging. Lisbon, Portugal, 2015. pp. 44-53
@inproceedings{f4f0413bd79b41319f546b475f55b523,
title = "Research article – Optimisation of paediatrics computed radiographyfor full spine curvature measurements using a phantom: a pilot study",
abstract = "Aim: Optimise a set of exposure factors, with the lowest effective dose, to delineate spinal curvature with the modified Cobb method in a full spine using computed radiography (CR) for a 5-year-old paediatric anthropomorphic phantom.Methods: Images were acquired by varying a set of parameters: positions (antero-posterior (AP), posteroanterior (PA) and lateral), kilo-voltage peak (kVp) (66-90), source-to-image distance (SID) (150 to 200cm), broad focus and the use of a grid (grid in/out) to analyse the impact on E and image quality(IQ). IQ was analysed applying two approaches: objective [contrast-to-noise-ratio/(CNR] and perceptual, using 5 observers. Monte-Carlo modelling was used for dose estimation. Cohen’s Kappa coefficient was used to calculate inter-observer-variability. The angle was measured using Cobb’s method on lateralprojections under different imaging conditions.Results: PA promoted the lowest effective dose (0.013 mSv) compared to AP (0.048 mSv) and lateral (0.025 mSv). The exposure parameters that allowed lower dose were 200cm SID, 90 kVp, broad focus and grid out for paediatrics using an Agfa CR system. Thirty-seven images were assessed for IQ andthirty-two were classified adequate. Cobb angle measurements varied between 16°±2.9 and 19.9°±0.9.Conclusion: Cobb angle measurements can be performed using the lowest dose with a low contrast-tonoise ratio. The variation on measurements for this was ±2.9° and this is within the range of acceptable clinical error without impact on clinical diagnosis. Further work is recommended on improvement tothe sample size and a more robust perceptual IQ assessment protocol for observers.",
keywords = "optimalisatie, ruggengraat, metingen, dosering, beeldkwaliteit, pediatrie, computertomografie, optimisation, spinal curvature measurements, effective dose, image quality, paediatrics, imaging phantom, computed radiography",
author = "{de Haan}, Seraphine and Cl{\'a}udia Reis and Junior Ndlovu and Catarina Serrenho and Ifrah Akhtar and Garcia, {Jos{\'e} Antonio} and Dani{\"e}l Linde and Martine Thorskog and Loris Franco and Peter Hogg",
note = "References.",
year = "2015",
language = "English",
pages = "44--53",
booktitle = "OPTIMAX 2014 – radiation dose and image quality optimisation in medical imaging",

}

de Haan, S, Reis, C, Ndlovu, J, Serrenho, C, Akhtar, I, Garcia, JA, Linde, D, Thorskog, M, Franco, L & Hogg, P 2015, Research article – Optimisation of paediatrics computed radiographyfor full spine curvature measurements using a phantom: a pilot study. in OPTIMAX 2014 – radiation dose and image quality optimisation in medical imaging. Lisbon, Portugal, pp. 44-53, OPTIMAX 2014, Lisbon , Portugal, 1/08/14.

Research article – Optimisation of paediatrics computed radiographyfor full spine curvature measurements using a phantom: a pilot study. / de Haan, Seraphine; Reis, Cláudia; Ndlovu, Junior; Serrenho, Catarina; Akhtar, Ifrah; Garcia, José Antonio; Linde, Daniël; Thorskog, Martine; Franco, Loris; Hogg, Peter.

OPTIMAX 2014 – radiation dose and image quality optimisation in medical imaging. Lisbon, Portugal, 2015. p. 44-53.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingContribution to conference proceedingAcademicpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Research article – Optimisation of paediatrics computed radiographyfor full spine curvature measurements using a phantom: a pilot study

AU - de Haan, Seraphine

AU - Reis, Cláudia

AU - Ndlovu, Junior

AU - Serrenho, Catarina

AU - Akhtar, Ifrah

AU - Garcia, José Antonio

AU - Linde, Daniël

AU - Thorskog, Martine

AU - Franco, Loris

AU - Hogg, Peter

N1 - References.

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Aim: Optimise a set of exposure factors, with the lowest effective dose, to delineate spinal curvature with the modified Cobb method in a full spine using computed radiography (CR) for a 5-year-old paediatric anthropomorphic phantom.Methods: Images were acquired by varying a set of parameters: positions (antero-posterior (AP), posteroanterior (PA) and lateral), kilo-voltage peak (kVp) (66-90), source-to-image distance (SID) (150 to 200cm), broad focus and the use of a grid (grid in/out) to analyse the impact on E and image quality(IQ). IQ was analysed applying two approaches: objective [contrast-to-noise-ratio/(CNR] and perceptual, using 5 observers. Monte-Carlo modelling was used for dose estimation. Cohen’s Kappa coefficient was used to calculate inter-observer-variability. The angle was measured using Cobb’s method on lateralprojections under different imaging conditions.Results: PA promoted the lowest effective dose (0.013 mSv) compared to AP (0.048 mSv) and lateral (0.025 mSv). The exposure parameters that allowed lower dose were 200cm SID, 90 kVp, broad focus and grid out for paediatrics using an Agfa CR system. Thirty-seven images were assessed for IQ andthirty-two were classified adequate. Cobb angle measurements varied between 16°±2.9 and 19.9°±0.9.Conclusion: Cobb angle measurements can be performed using the lowest dose with a low contrast-tonoise ratio. The variation on measurements for this was ±2.9° and this is within the range of acceptable clinical error without impact on clinical diagnosis. Further work is recommended on improvement tothe sample size and a more robust perceptual IQ assessment protocol for observers.

AB - Aim: Optimise a set of exposure factors, with the lowest effective dose, to delineate spinal curvature with the modified Cobb method in a full spine using computed radiography (CR) for a 5-year-old paediatric anthropomorphic phantom.Methods: Images were acquired by varying a set of parameters: positions (antero-posterior (AP), posteroanterior (PA) and lateral), kilo-voltage peak (kVp) (66-90), source-to-image distance (SID) (150 to 200cm), broad focus and the use of a grid (grid in/out) to analyse the impact on E and image quality(IQ). IQ was analysed applying two approaches: objective [contrast-to-noise-ratio/(CNR] and perceptual, using 5 observers. Monte-Carlo modelling was used for dose estimation. Cohen’s Kappa coefficient was used to calculate inter-observer-variability. The angle was measured using Cobb’s method on lateralprojections under different imaging conditions.Results: PA promoted the lowest effective dose (0.013 mSv) compared to AP (0.048 mSv) and lateral (0.025 mSv). The exposure parameters that allowed lower dose were 200cm SID, 90 kVp, broad focus and grid out for paediatrics using an Agfa CR system. Thirty-seven images were assessed for IQ andthirty-two were classified adequate. Cobb angle measurements varied between 16°±2.9 and 19.9°±0.9.Conclusion: Cobb angle measurements can be performed using the lowest dose with a low contrast-tonoise ratio. The variation on measurements for this was ±2.9° and this is within the range of acceptable clinical error without impact on clinical diagnosis. Further work is recommended on improvement tothe sample size and a more robust perceptual IQ assessment protocol for observers.

KW - optimalisatie

KW - ruggengraat

KW - metingen

KW - dosering

KW - beeldkwaliteit

KW - pediatrie

KW - computertomografie

KW - optimisation

KW - spinal curvature measurements

KW - effective dose

KW - image quality

KW - paediatrics

KW - imaging phantom

KW - computed radiography

UR - http://usir.salford.ac.uk/34439/

M3 - Contribution to conference proceeding

SP - 44

EP - 53

BT - OPTIMAX 2014 – radiation dose and image quality optimisation in medical imaging

CY - Lisbon, Portugal

ER -

de Haan S, Reis C, Ndlovu J, Serrenho C, Akhtar I, Garcia JA et al. Research article – Optimisation of paediatrics computed radiographyfor full spine curvature measurements using a phantom: a pilot study. In OPTIMAX 2014 – radiation dose and image quality optimisation in medical imaging. Lisbon, Portugal. 2015. p. 44-53