Non score-dependency: theory and assessment

Robert Harris, Peter van Kranenburg, Bauke de Jong

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingContribution to conference proceedingAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Untrained listeners demonstrate implicit knowledge of syntactic patterns
and principles. Untrained generative music ability, for example singing,
humming, and whistling, is a largely unconscious or intuitive application
of these patterns and principles. From the viewpoint of embodied cognition,
listening to music should evoke an internal representation or motor
image which, together with the perception of organized music, should
form the basis of musical cognition. Indeed, that is what listeners demonstrate
when they sing, hum, or whistle familiar and unfamiliar tunes or
when they vocally or orally improvise continuations to interrupted
phrases. Research on vocal improvisation using continuations sung to an
interrupted musical phrase, has shown that one’s cultural background
influences the music generated. That should be the case for instrumentalists
as well: when they play familiar or unfamiliar tunes by ear in different
keys (transposition) or when they improvise variations,
accompaniments, or continuations to interrupted phrases, the music they
generate should reflect the same cognitive structures as their oral improvisations.
This study is attempting to validate a test of (non) scoredependency
that will enable assessment of the music student’s implicit
knowledge of these structures during performance on the principal instrument.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of ISPS 2011
EditorsAaron Williamon, Darryl Edwards, Lee Bartel
Place of PublicationUtrecht
PublisherAssociation Européenne des Conservatoires, Académies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC)
Pages365-368
ISBN (Print)978-94-90306-02-1
Publication statusPublished - 2011
Event3rd International Symposium on Performance Science (ISPS) 2011: Models of Performance - Faculty of Music, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada
Duration: 24 Aug 201127 Aug 2011
Conference number: 3rd
http://www.performancescience.org/ISPS2011/

Conference

Conference3rd International Symposium on Performance Science (ISPS) 2011
Abbreviated titleISPS 2011
CountryCanada
CityToronto
Period24/08/1127/08/11
Internet address

Keywords

  • non score-dependency
  • improvisation
  • assessment
  • oral proficiency
  • performance

Cite this

Harris, R., van Kranenburg, P., & de Jong, B. (2011). Non score-dependency: theory and assessment. In A. Williamon, D. Edwards, & L. Bartel (Eds.), Proceedings of ISPS 2011 (pp. 365-368). Utrecht: Association Européenne des Conservatoires, Académies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC).
Harris, Robert ; van Kranenburg, Peter ; de Jong, Bauke. / Non score-dependency : theory and assessment. Proceedings of ISPS 2011. editor / Aaron Williamon ; Darryl Edwards ; Lee Bartel. Utrecht : Association Européenne des Conservatoires, Académies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC), 2011. pp. 365-368
@inproceedings{3438d511e0bd4d648f5b6f0ac75eeba3,
title = "Non score-dependency: theory and assessment",
abstract = "Untrained listeners demonstrate implicit knowledge of syntactic patternsand principles. Untrained generative music ability, for example singing,humming, and whistling, is a largely unconscious or intuitive applicationof these patterns and principles. From the viewpoint of embodied cognition,listening to music should evoke an internal representation or motorimage which, together with the perception of organized music, shouldform the basis of musical cognition. Indeed, that is what listeners demonstratewhen they sing, hum, or whistle familiar and unfamiliar tunes orwhen they vocally or orally improvise continuations to interruptedphrases. Research on vocal improvisation using continuations sung to aninterrupted musical phrase, has shown that one’s cultural backgroundinfluences the music generated. That should be the case for instrumentalistsas well: when they play familiar or unfamiliar tunes by ear in differentkeys (transposition) or when they improvise variations,accompaniments, or continuations to interrupted phrases, the music theygenerate should reflect the same cognitive structures as their oral improvisations.This study is attempting to validate a test of (non) scoredependencythat will enable assessment of the music student’s implicitknowledge of these structures during performance on the principal instrument.",
keywords = "non score-dependency, improvisation, assessment, oral proficiency, performance, muziek, opvoeding",
author = "Robert Harris and {van Kranenburg}, Peter and {de Jong}, Bauke",
year = "2011",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-94-90306-02-1",
pages = "365--368",
editor = "Aaron Williamon and Darryl Edwards and Lee Bartel",
booktitle = "Proceedings of ISPS 2011",
publisher = "Association Europ{\'e}enne des Conservatoires, Acad{\'e}mies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC)",

}

Harris, R, van Kranenburg, P & de Jong, B 2011, Non score-dependency: theory and assessment. in A Williamon, D Edwards & L Bartel (eds), Proceedings of ISPS 2011. Association Européenne des Conservatoires, Académies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC), Utrecht, pp. 365-368, 3rd International Symposium on Performance Science (ISPS) 2011, Toronto, Canada, 24/08/11.

Non score-dependency : theory and assessment. / Harris, Robert; van Kranenburg, Peter; de Jong, Bauke.

Proceedings of ISPS 2011. ed. / Aaron Williamon; Darryl Edwards; Lee Bartel. Utrecht : Association Européenne des Conservatoires, Académies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC), 2011. p. 365-368.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingContribution to conference proceedingAcademicpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Non score-dependency

T2 - theory and assessment

AU - Harris, Robert

AU - van Kranenburg, Peter

AU - de Jong, Bauke

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - Untrained listeners demonstrate implicit knowledge of syntactic patternsand principles. Untrained generative music ability, for example singing,humming, and whistling, is a largely unconscious or intuitive applicationof these patterns and principles. From the viewpoint of embodied cognition,listening to music should evoke an internal representation or motorimage which, together with the perception of organized music, shouldform the basis of musical cognition. Indeed, that is what listeners demonstratewhen they sing, hum, or whistle familiar and unfamiliar tunes orwhen they vocally or orally improvise continuations to interruptedphrases. Research on vocal improvisation using continuations sung to aninterrupted musical phrase, has shown that one’s cultural backgroundinfluences the music generated. That should be the case for instrumentalistsas well: when they play familiar or unfamiliar tunes by ear in differentkeys (transposition) or when they improvise variations,accompaniments, or continuations to interrupted phrases, the music theygenerate should reflect the same cognitive structures as their oral improvisations.This study is attempting to validate a test of (non) scoredependencythat will enable assessment of the music student’s implicitknowledge of these structures during performance on the principal instrument.

AB - Untrained listeners demonstrate implicit knowledge of syntactic patternsand principles. Untrained generative music ability, for example singing,humming, and whistling, is a largely unconscious or intuitive applicationof these patterns and principles. From the viewpoint of embodied cognition,listening to music should evoke an internal representation or motorimage which, together with the perception of organized music, shouldform the basis of musical cognition. Indeed, that is what listeners demonstratewhen they sing, hum, or whistle familiar and unfamiliar tunes orwhen they vocally or orally improvise continuations to interruptedphrases. Research on vocal improvisation using continuations sung to aninterrupted musical phrase, has shown that one’s cultural backgroundinfluences the music generated. That should be the case for instrumentalistsas well: when they play familiar or unfamiliar tunes by ear in differentkeys (transposition) or when they improvise variations,accompaniments, or continuations to interrupted phrases, the music theygenerate should reflect the same cognitive structures as their oral improvisations.This study is attempting to validate a test of (non) scoredependencythat will enable assessment of the music student’s implicitknowledge of these structures during performance on the principal instrument.

KW - non score-dependency

KW - improvisation

KW - assessment

KW - oral proficiency

KW - performance

KW - muziek

KW - opvoeding

M3 - Contribution to conference proceeding

SN - 978-94-90306-02-1

SP - 365

EP - 368

BT - Proceedings of ISPS 2011

A2 - Williamon, Aaron

A2 - Edwards, Darryl

A2 - Bartel, Lee

PB - Association Européenne des Conservatoires, Académies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC)

CY - Utrecht

ER -

Harris R, van Kranenburg P, de Jong B. Non score-dependency: theory and assessment. In Williamon A, Edwards D, Bartel L, editors, Proceedings of ISPS 2011. Utrecht: Association Européenne des Conservatoires, Académies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC). 2011. p. 365-368