Liability and damage claim issues in induced earthquakes: case of Groningen

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademic

Abstract

Groningen gas field is the largest on-land gas resource in the world and is being
exploited since 1963. There are damaging earthquakes, the largest of which was 3.6 magnitude. The recursive induced earthquakes are often blamed for triggering the structural damages in thousands of houses in the area. A damage claim procedure takes place after each significantly felt earthquake. The liability of the exploiting company is related to the damages and the engineering firms and experts are asked to correlate the claimed damages with a past earthquake. Structures in the region present high vulnerabilities to the lateral forces, soil
properties are quite unfavourable for seismic resistance, and structural damages are present even without earthquakes. This situation creates a dispute area where one can claim that most structures in the region were already damaged because of the fact that the soil is soft, the ground water table oscillates, and structures are vulnerable to external conditions anyhow and deteriorate in time, which can be the main cause of such structural damages. This ambiguity of damage vs earthquake correlation is one of the main sources of the public unrest in the area up until today. This study presents the perspective of people in the region in terms of liveability and the social acceptance of earthquakes in their lives. An attempt has been made to translate these social effects and expectations into structural performance metrics for ordinary houses in the region. A new seismic design and assessment approach, called Comfort Level Earthquake (CLE) has been proposed.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages10
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2019
EventSECED - UK National Conference on Earthquake Engineering - Greenwich, London, United Kingdom
Duration: 9 Sep 201910 Sep 2019
https://www.seced.org.uk/index.php/seced-2019

Conference

ConferenceSECED - UK National Conference on Earthquake Engineering
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityLondon
Period9/09/1910/09/19
Internet address

Keywords

  • earthquakes

Cite this

Bal, I. E., Smyrou, E., & Bulder, E. (2019). Liability and damage claim issues in induced earthquakes: case of Groningen. Paper presented at SECED - UK National Conference on Earthquake Engineering, London, United Kingdom.
Bal, Ihsan Engin ; Smyrou, Eleni ; Bulder, Elisabeth. / Liability and damage claim issues in induced earthquakes: case of Groningen. Paper presented at SECED - UK National Conference on Earthquake Engineering, London, United Kingdom.10 p.
@conference{f8e7cb2a4e704aacbe8e3a82c098f160,
title = "Liability and damage claim issues in induced earthquakes: case of Groningen",
abstract = "Groningen gas field is the largest on-land gas resource in the world and is beingexploited since 1963. There are damaging earthquakes, the largest of which was 3.6 magnitude. The recursive induced earthquakes are often blamed for triggering the structural damages in thousands of houses in the area. A damage claim procedure takes place after each significantly felt earthquake. The liability of the exploiting company is related to the damages and the engineering firms and experts are asked to correlate the claimed damages with a past earthquake. Structures in the region present high vulnerabilities to the lateral forces, soilproperties are quite unfavourable for seismic resistance, and structural damages are present even without earthquakes. This situation creates a dispute area where one can claim that most structures in the region were already damaged because of the fact that the soil is soft, the ground water table oscillates, and structures are vulnerable to external conditions anyhow and deteriorate in time, which can be the main cause of such structural damages. This ambiguity of damage vs earthquake correlation is one of the main sources of the public unrest in the area up until today. This study presents the perspective of people in the region in terms of liveability and the social acceptance of earthquakes in their lives. An attempt has been made to translate these social effects and expectations into structural performance metrics for ordinary houses in the region. A new seismic design and assessment approach, called Comfort Level Earthquake (CLE) has been proposed.",
keywords = "earthquakes, aardbevingen",
author = "Bal, {Ihsan Engin} and Eleni Smyrou and Elisabeth Bulder",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
language = "English",
note = "null ; Conference date: 09-09-2019 Through 10-09-2019",
url = "https://www.seced.org.uk/index.php/seced-2019",

}

Bal, IE, Smyrou, E & Bulder, E 2019, 'Liability and damage claim issues in induced earthquakes: case of Groningen' Paper presented at, London, United Kingdom, 9/09/19 - 10/09/19, .

Liability and damage claim issues in induced earthquakes: case of Groningen. / Bal, Ihsan Engin; Smyrou, Eleni; Bulder, Elisabeth.

2019. Paper presented at SECED - UK National Conference on Earthquake Engineering, London, United Kingdom.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademic

TY - CONF

T1 - Liability and damage claim issues in induced earthquakes: case of Groningen

AU - Bal, Ihsan Engin

AU - Smyrou, Eleni

AU - Bulder, Elisabeth

PY - 2019/9

Y1 - 2019/9

N2 - Groningen gas field is the largest on-land gas resource in the world and is beingexploited since 1963. There are damaging earthquakes, the largest of which was 3.6 magnitude. The recursive induced earthquakes are often blamed for triggering the structural damages in thousands of houses in the area. A damage claim procedure takes place after each significantly felt earthquake. The liability of the exploiting company is related to the damages and the engineering firms and experts are asked to correlate the claimed damages with a past earthquake. Structures in the region present high vulnerabilities to the lateral forces, soilproperties are quite unfavourable for seismic resistance, and structural damages are present even without earthquakes. This situation creates a dispute area where one can claim that most structures in the region were already damaged because of the fact that the soil is soft, the ground water table oscillates, and structures are vulnerable to external conditions anyhow and deteriorate in time, which can be the main cause of such structural damages. This ambiguity of damage vs earthquake correlation is one of the main sources of the public unrest in the area up until today. This study presents the perspective of people in the region in terms of liveability and the social acceptance of earthquakes in their lives. An attempt has been made to translate these social effects and expectations into structural performance metrics for ordinary houses in the region. A new seismic design and assessment approach, called Comfort Level Earthquake (CLE) has been proposed.

AB - Groningen gas field is the largest on-land gas resource in the world and is beingexploited since 1963. There are damaging earthquakes, the largest of which was 3.6 magnitude. The recursive induced earthquakes are often blamed for triggering the structural damages in thousands of houses in the area. A damage claim procedure takes place after each significantly felt earthquake. The liability of the exploiting company is related to the damages and the engineering firms and experts are asked to correlate the claimed damages with a past earthquake. Structures in the region present high vulnerabilities to the lateral forces, soilproperties are quite unfavourable for seismic resistance, and structural damages are present even without earthquakes. This situation creates a dispute area where one can claim that most structures in the region were already damaged because of the fact that the soil is soft, the ground water table oscillates, and structures are vulnerable to external conditions anyhow and deteriorate in time, which can be the main cause of such structural damages. This ambiguity of damage vs earthquake correlation is one of the main sources of the public unrest in the area up until today. This study presents the perspective of people in the region in terms of liveability and the social acceptance of earthquakes in their lives. An attempt has been made to translate these social effects and expectations into structural performance metrics for ordinary houses in the region. A new seismic design and assessment approach, called Comfort Level Earthquake (CLE) has been proposed.

KW - earthquakes

KW - aardbevingen

M3 - Paper

ER -

Bal IE, Smyrou E, Bulder E. Liability and damage claim issues in induced earthquakes: case of Groningen. 2019. Paper presented at SECED - UK National Conference on Earthquake Engineering, London, United Kingdom.