How partner gender influences female students’ problem solving in physics education

Ning Ding, Egbert Harskamp

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › Academic › peer-review

8 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Research has shown that female students cannot profit as much as male students can from cooperative learning in physics, especially in mixed-gender dyads. This study has explored the influence of partner gender on female students’ learning achievement, interaction and the problem-solving process during cooperative learning. In Shanghai, a total of 50 students (26 females and 24 males), drawn from two classes of a high school, took part in the study. Students were randomly paired, and there were three research groups: mixed-gender dyads (MG), female–female dyads (FF) and male–male dyads (MM). Analysis of students’ pre- and post-test performances revealed that female students in the single-gender condition solved physics problems more effectively than did those in the mixed-gender condition, while the same was not the case for male students. We further explored the differences between female and male communication styles, and content among the three research groups. It showed that the females’ interaction content and problem-solving processes were more sensitive to partner gender than were those for males. This might explain why mixed-gender cooperation in physics disadvantages females in high schools.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)331-343
JournalJournal of science education and technology
Volume15
Issue number5
Publication statusPublished - 2006

Fingerprint

female student
physics
Physics
Education
Students
dyad
gender
education
cooperative learning
student
interaction
school
profit
Group
Profitability
communication
Communication
learning
performance

Keywords

  • learning process

Cite this

Ding, Ning ; Harskamp, Egbert. / How partner gender influences female students’ problem solving in physics education. In: Journal of science education and technology. 2006 ; Vol. 15, No. 5. pp. 331-343.
@article{348728ba96fd456580ee8a5eda9cf302,
title = "How partner gender influences female students’ problem solving in physics education",
abstract = "Research has shown that female students cannot profit as much as male students can from cooperative learning in physics, especially in mixed-gender dyads. This study has explored the influence of partner gender on female students’ learning achievement, interaction and the problem-solving process during cooperative learning. In Shanghai, a total of 50 students (26 females and 24 males), drawn from two classes of a high school, took part in the study. Students were randomly paired, and there were three research groups: mixed-gender dyads (MG), female–female dyads (FF) and male–male dyads (MM). Analysis of students’ pre- and post-test performances revealed that female students in the single-gender condition solved physics problems more effectively than did those in the mixed-gender condition, while the same was not the case for male students. We further explored the differences between female and male communication styles, and content among the three research groups. It showed that the females’ interaction content and problem-solving processes were more sensitive to partner gender than were those for males. This might explain why mixed-gender cooperation in physics disadvantages females in high schools.",
keywords = "wetenschapseducatie, gender, leerprocessen, learning process",
author = "Ning Ding and Egbert Harskamp",
year = "2006",
language = "English",
volume = "15",
pages = "331--343",
journal = "Journal of science education and technology",
issn = "1573-1839",
publisher = "Springer Science + Business Media",
number = "5",

}

Ding, N & Harskamp, E 2006, 'How partner gender influences female students’ problem solving in physics education', Journal of science education and technology, vol. 15, no. 5, pp. 331-343.

How partner gender influences female students’ problem solving in physics education. / Ding, Ning; Harskamp, Egbert.

In: Journal of science education and technology, Vol. 15, No. 5, 2006, p. 331-343.

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › Academic › peer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - How partner gender influences female students’ problem solving in physics education

AU - Ding, Ning

AU - Harskamp, Egbert

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - Research has shown that female students cannot profit as much as male students can from cooperative learning in physics, especially in mixed-gender dyads. This study has explored the influence of partner gender on female students’ learning achievement, interaction and the problem-solving process during cooperative learning. In Shanghai, a total of 50 students (26 females and 24 males), drawn from two classes of a high school, took part in the study. Students were randomly paired, and there were three research groups: mixed-gender dyads (MG), female–female dyads (FF) and male–male dyads (MM). Analysis of students’ pre- and post-test performances revealed that female students in the single-gender condition solved physics problems more effectively than did those in the mixed-gender condition, while the same was not the case for male students. We further explored the differences between female and male communication styles, and content among the three research groups. It showed that the females’ interaction content and problem-solving processes were more sensitive to partner gender than were those for males. This might explain why mixed-gender cooperation in physics disadvantages females in high schools.

AB - Research has shown that female students cannot profit as much as male students can from cooperative learning in physics, especially in mixed-gender dyads. This study has explored the influence of partner gender on female students’ learning achievement, interaction and the problem-solving process during cooperative learning. In Shanghai, a total of 50 students (26 females and 24 males), drawn from two classes of a high school, took part in the study. Students were randomly paired, and there were three research groups: mixed-gender dyads (MG), female–female dyads (FF) and male–male dyads (MM). Analysis of students’ pre- and post-test performances revealed that female students in the single-gender condition solved physics problems more effectively than did those in the mixed-gender condition, while the same was not the case for male students. We further explored the differences between female and male communication styles, and content among the three research groups. It showed that the females’ interaction content and problem-solving processes were more sensitive to partner gender than were those for males. This might explain why mixed-gender cooperation in physics disadvantages females in high schools.

KW - wetenschapseducatie

KW - gender

KW - leerprocessen

KW - learning process

M3 - Article

VL - 15

SP - 331

EP - 343

JO - Journal of science education and technology

JF - Journal of science education and technology

SN - 1573-1839

IS - 5

ER -

Ding N, Harskamp E. How partner gender influences female students’ problem solving in physics education. Journal of science education and technology. 2006;15(5):331-343.

Access to Document