Heritage, social values and the threat of ruination

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademic

12 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Valuation of heritage buildings is usually performed by architectural-historical experts, who use a typology of heritage values based on conservation philosophy. Increasingly, social and spirituality values are included in heritage assessment frameworks.
What happens to valuation systems when external events influence the chances of survival of heritage buildings, such as earthquakes induced by gas extraction in the Netherlands? While the mining company uses a narrow economic perspective on value, the public fears for loss of character of their historic towns. New safety regulations constitute a new and even stronger threat to heritage buildings. Recently, a heritage assessment framework was published, to help with value assessments in the affected region. In this paper, we compare experts’ and laypersons’ values by analyzing the new assessment framework as well as public documents. We conclude that heritage value assessments should incorporate social values, including memories and symbolic meanings, to create a balanced valuation system.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages8
Publication statusIn preparation - 28 Feb 2018
EventEEHB 2018: The 3rd International Conference on Energy Efficiency in Historic Buildings - Visby, Visby, Sweden
Duration: 26 Sep 201827 Sep 2018

Conference

ConferenceEEHB 2018
CountrySweden
CityVisby
Period26/09/1827/09/18

Keywords

  • historical buildings
  • heritage
  • earthquakes
  • valuation systems
  • livability
  • ruination

Cite this

van der Schoor, T. (2018). Heritage, social values and the threat of ruination. Paper presented at EEHB 2018, Visby, Sweden.
van der Schoor, Tineke. / Heritage, social values and the threat of ruination. Paper presented at EEHB 2018, Visby, Sweden.8 p.
@conference{af41ffb89c1d46d7a7aa90ab77cab81d,
title = "Heritage, social values and the threat of ruination",
abstract = "Valuation of heritage buildings is usually performed by architectural-historical experts, who use a typology of heritage values based on conservation philosophy. Increasingly, social and spirituality values are included in heritage assessment frameworks.What happens to valuation systems when external events influence the chances of survival of heritage buildings, such as earthquakes induced by gas extraction in the Netherlands? While the mining company uses a narrow economic perspective on value, the public fears for loss of character of their historic towns. New safety regulations constitute a new and even stronger threat to heritage buildings. Recently, a heritage assessment framework was published, to help with value assessments in the affected region. In this paper, we compare experts’ and laypersons’ values by analyzing the new assessment framework as well as public documents. We conclude that heritage value assessments should incorporate social values, including memories and symbolic meanings, to create a balanced valuation system.",
keywords = "historische gebouwen, erfgoed, aardbevingsgebieden, waardensystemen, leefbaarheid, historical buildings, heritage, earthquakes, valuation systems, livability, ruination",
author = "{van der Schoor}, Tineke",
year = "2018",
month = "2",
day = "28",
language = "English",
note = "null ; Conference date: 26-09-2018 Through 27-09-2018",

}

van der Schoor, T 2018, 'Heritage, social values and the threat of ruination' Paper presented at, Visby, Sweden, 26/09/18 - 27/09/18, .

Heritage, social values and the threat of ruination. / van der Schoor, Tineke.

2018. Paper presented at EEHB 2018, Visby, Sweden.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademic

TY - CONF

T1 - Heritage, social values and the threat of ruination

AU - van der Schoor, Tineke

PY - 2018/2/28

Y1 - 2018/2/28

N2 - Valuation of heritage buildings is usually performed by architectural-historical experts, who use a typology of heritage values based on conservation philosophy. Increasingly, social and spirituality values are included in heritage assessment frameworks.What happens to valuation systems when external events influence the chances of survival of heritage buildings, such as earthquakes induced by gas extraction in the Netherlands? While the mining company uses a narrow economic perspective on value, the public fears for loss of character of their historic towns. New safety regulations constitute a new and even stronger threat to heritage buildings. Recently, a heritage assessment framework was published, to help with value assessments in the affected region. In this paper, we compare experts’ and laypersons’ values by analyzing the new assessment framework as well as public documents. We conclude that heritage value assessments should incorporate social values, including memories and symbolic meanings, to create a balanced valuation system.

AB - Valuation of heritage buildings is usually performed by architectural-historical experts, who use a typology of heritage values based on conservation philosophy. Increasingly, social and spirituality values are included in heritage assessment frameworks.What happens to valuation systems when external events influence the chances of survival of heritage buildings, such as earthquakes induced by gas extraction in the Netherlands? While the mining company uses a narrow economic perspective on value, the public fears for loss of character of their historic towns. New safety regulations constitute a new and even stronger threat to heritage buildings. Recently, a heritage assessment framework was published, to help with value assessments in the affected region. In this paper, we compare experts’ and laypersons’ values by analyzing the new assessment framework as well as public documents. We conclude that heritage value assessments should incorporate social values, including memories and symbolic meanings, to create a balanced valuation system.

KW - historische gebouwen

KW - erfgoed

KW - aardbevingsgebieden

KW - waardensystemen

KW - leefbaarheid

KW - historical buildings

KW - heritage

KW - earthquakes

KW - valuation systems

KW - livability

KW - ruination

UR - http://eehb2018.com/

M3 - Paper

ER -

van der Schoor T. Heritage, social values and the threat of ruination. 2018. Paper presented at EEHB 2018, Visby, Sweden.