An assessment framework of business modelling ontologies to ensure the viability of business models

Austin D'Souza, Nick van Beest, George. B. Huitema, J.C. Wortmann, Hugo Velthuijsen

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperOther research output

31 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Organisations operate in an increasingly dynamic environment. Consequently, the business models span several organisations, dealing with multiple stakeholders and their competing interests. As a result, the enterprise information systems supporting this new market setting are highly distributed, and their components are owned and managed by different stakeholders. For successful businesses to exist it is crucial that their enterprise architectures are derived from and aligned with viable business models. Business model ontologies (BMOs) are effective tools for designing and evaluating business models. However, the viability perspective has been largely neglected. In this paper, current BMOs have been assessed on their capabilities to support the design and evaluation of viable business models. As such, a list of criteria is derived from literature to evaluate BMOs from a viability perspective. These criteria are subsequently applied to six well-established BMOs, to identify a BMO best suited for design and evaluation of viable business models. The analysis reveals that, although none of the BMOs satisfy all the criteria, e3-value is the most appropriate BMO for designing and evaluating business models from a viability perspective. Furthermore, the identified deficits provide clear areas for enhancing the assessed BMOs from a viability perspective.
Original languageEnglish
Pages226-235
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2014
Event16th International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems (ICEIS) 2014 - Lisbon, Portugal
Duration: 27 Apr 201430 Apr 2014
Conference number: 16th
http://www.iceis.org/?y=2014

Conference

Conference16th International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems (ICEIS) 2014
Abbreviated titleICEIS 2014
CountryPortugal
CityLisbon
Period27/04/1430/04/14
Internet address

Keywords

  • business models
  • ontologies
  • strategic management
  • viability

Cite this

D'Souza, A., van Beest, N., Huitema, G. B., Wortmann, J. C., & Velthuijsen, H. (2014). An assessment framework of business modelling ontologies to ensure the viability of business models. 226-235. Paper presented at 16th International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems (ICEIS) 2014, Lisbon, Portugal.
D'Souza, Austin ; van Beest, Nick ; Huitema, George. B. ; Wortmann, J.C. ; Velthuijsen, Hugo. / An assessment framework of business modelling ontologies to ensure the viability of business models. Paper presented at 16th International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems (ICEIS) 2014, Lisbon, Portugal.
@conference{02e52cda5fb24b03a200c024fa610811,
title = "An assessment framework of business modelling ontologies to ensure the viability of business models",
abstract = "Organisations operate in an increasingly dynamic environment. Consequently, the business models span several organisations, dealing with multiple stakeholders and their competing interests. As a result, the enterprise information systems supporting this new market setting are highly distributed, and their components are owned and managed by different stakeholders. For successful businesses to exist it is crucial that their enterprise architectures are derived from and aligned with viable business models. Business model ontologies (BMOs) are effective tools for designing and evaluating business models. However, the viability perspective has been largely neglected. In this paper, current BMOs have been assessed on their capabilities to support the design and evaluation of viable business models. As such, a list of criteria is derived from literature to evaluate BMOs from a viability perspective. These criteria are subsequently applied to six well-established BMOs, to identify a BMO best suited for design and evaluation of viable business models. The analysis reveals that, although none of the BMOs satisfy all the criteria, e3-value is the most appropriate BMO for designing and evaluating business models from a viability perspective. Furthermore, the identified deficits provide clear areas for enhancing the assessed BMOs from a viability perspective.",
keywords = "bedrijfsmodellen, ontologie{\"e}n, strategisch management, levensvatbaarheid, business models, ontologies, strategic management, viability",
author = "Austin D'Souza and {van Beest}, Nick and Huitema, {George. B.} and J.C. Wortmann and Hugo Velthuijsen",
year = "2014",
month = "4",
language = "English",
pages = "226--235",
note = "null ; Conference date: 27-04-2014 Through 30-04-2014",
url = "http://www.iceis.org/?y=2014",

}

D'Souza, A, van Beest, N, Huitema, GB, Wortmann, JC & Velthuijsen, H 2014, 'An assessment framework of business modelling ontologies to ensure the viability of business models' Paper presented at, Lisbon, Portugal, 27/04/14 - 30/04/14, pp. 226-235.

An assessment framework of business modelling ontologies to ensure the viability of business models. / D'Souza, Austin; van Beest, Nick; Huitema, George. B.; Wortmann, J.C.; Velthuijsen, Hugo.

2014. 226-235 Paper presented at 16th International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems (ICEIS) 2014, Lisbon, Portugal.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperOther research output

TY - CONF

T1 - An assessment framework of business modelling ontologies to ensure the viability of business models

AU - D'Souza, Austin

AU - van Beest, Nick

AU - Huitema, George. B.

AU - Wortmann, J.C.

AU - Velthuijsen, Hugo

PY - 2014/4

Y1 - 2014/4

N2 - Organisations operate in an increasingly dynamic environment. Consequently, the business models span several organisations, dealing with multiple stakeholders and their competing interests. As a result, the enterprise information systems supporting this new market setting are highly distributed, and their components are owned and managed by different stakeholders. For successful businesses to exist it is crucial that their enterprise architectures are derived from and aligned with viable business models. Business model ontologies (BMOs) are effective tools for designing and evaluating business models. However, the viability perspective has been largely neglected. In this paper, current BMOs have been assessed on their capabilities to support the design and evaluation of viable business models. As such, a list of criteria is derived from literature to evaluate BMOs from a viability perspective. These criteria are subsequently applied to six well-established BMOs, to identify a BMO best suited for design and evaluation of viable business models. The analysis reveals that, although none of the BMOs satisfy all the criteria, e3-value is the most appropriate BMO for designing and evaluating business models from a viability perspective. Furthermore, the identified deficits provide clear areas for enhancing the assessed BMOs from a viability perspective.

AB - Organisations operate in an increasingly dynamic environment. Consequently, the business models span several organisations, dealing with multiple stakeholders and their competing interests. As a result, the enterprise information systems supporting this new market setting are highly distributed, and their components are owned and managed by different stakeholders. For successful businesses to exist it is crucial that their enterprise architectures are derived from and aligned with viable business models. Business model ontologies (BMOs) are effective tools for designing and evaluating business models. However, the viability perspective has been largely neglected. In this paper, current BMOs have been assessed on their capabilities to support the design and evaluation of viable business models. As such, a list of criteria is derived from literature to evaluate BMOs from a viability perspective. These criteria are subsequently applied to six well-established BMOs, to identify a BMO best suited for design and evaluation of viable business models. The analysis reveals that, although none of the BMOs satisfy all the criteria, e3-value is the most appropriate BMO for designing and evaluating business models from a viability perspective. Furthermore, the identified deficits provide clear areas for enhancing the assessed BMOs from a viability perspective.

KW - bedrijfsmodellen

KW - ontologieën

KW - strategisch management

KW - levensvatbaarheid

KW - business models

KW - ontologies

KW - strategic management

KW - viability

M3 - Paper

SP - 226

EP - 235

ER -

D'Souza A, van Beest N, Huitema GB, Wortmann JC, Velthuijsen H. An assessment framework of business modelling ontologies to ensure the viability of business models. 2014. Paper presented at 16th International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems (ICEIS) 2014, Lisbon, Portugal.