ADHD and Brain Anatomy: What Do Academic Textbooks used in the Netherlands Tell Students?

Sanne te Meerman, Laura Batstra, Justin Freedman, Rink Hoekstra, Hans Grietens

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Studies of brain size of children classified with ADHD appear to reveal smaller brains when compared to ‘normal’ children. Yet, what does this mean? Even with the use of rigorously screened case and control groups, these studies show only small, average group differences between children with and without an ADHD classification. However, academic textbooks used in the Netherlands often portray individual children with an ADHD classification as having a different, malfunctioning brain that necessitates medical intervention. This conceptualisation of ADHD might serve professional interests, but not necessarily the interests of children.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages15
JournalChildren & society
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12 Oct 2019

Fingerprint

Textbooks
Netherlands
Anatomy
Students
Brain
Case-Control Studies
Control Groups

Keywords

  • adhd
  • children's rights
  • medicalisation
  • image building
  • textbooks
  • the netherlands

Cite this

te Meerman, Sanne ; Batstra, Laura ; Freedman, Justin ; Hoekstra, Rink ; Grietens, Hans . / ADHD and Brain Anatomy : What Do Academic Textbooks used in the Netherlands Tell Students?. In: Children & society. 2019.
@article{85a55709930849b789c03aad30f9c577,
title = "ADHD and Brain Anatomy: What Do Academic Textbooks used in the Netherlands Tell Students?",
abstract = "Studies of brain size of children classified with ADHD appear to reveal smaller brains when compared to ‘normal’ children. Yet, what does this mean? Even with the use of rigorously screened case and control groups, these studies show only small, average group differences between children with and without an ADHD classification. However, academic textbooks used in the Netherlands often portray individual children with an ADHD classification as having a different, malfunctioning brain that necessitates medical intervention. This conceptualisation of ADHD might serve professional interests, but not necessarily the interests of children.",
keywords = "adhd, medicalisering, beeldvorming, leerboeken, textbooks, nederland, rechten van het kind, adhd, children's rights, medicalisation, image building, textbooks, the netherlands",
author = "{te Meerman}, Sanne and Laura Batstra and Justin Freedman and Rink Hoekstra and Hans Grietens",
note = "References.",
year = "2019",
month = "10",
day = "12",
doi = "10.1111/chso.12362",
language = "English",
journal = "Children & society",
issn = "1099-0860",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",

}

ADHD and Brain Anatomy : What Do Academic Textbooks used in the Netherlands Tell Students? / te Meerman, Sanne; Batstra, Laura; Freedman, Justin ; Hoekstra, Rink; Grietens, Hans .

In: Children & society, 12.10.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - ADHD and Brain Anatomy

T2 - What Do Academic Textbooks used in the Netherlands Tell Students?

AU - te Meerman, Sanne

AU - Batstra, Laura

AU - Freedman, Justin

AU - Hoekstra, Rink

AU - Grietens, Hans

N1 - References.

PY - 2019/10/12

Y1 - 2019/10/12

N2 - Studies of brain size of children classified with ADHD appear to reveal smaller brains when compared to ‘normal’ children. Yet, what does this mean? Even with the use of rigorously screened case and control groups, these studies show only small, average group differences between children with and without an ADHD classification. However, academic textbooks used in the Netherlands often portray individual children with an ADHD classification as having a different, malfunctioning brain that necessitates medical intervention. This conceptualisation of ADHD might serve professional interests, but not necessarily the interests of children.

AB - Studies of brain size of children classified with ADHD appear to reveal smaller brains when compared to ‘normal’ children. Yet, what does this mean? Even with the use of rigorously screened case and control groups, these studies show only small, average group differences between children with and without an ADHD classification. However, academic textbooks used in the Netherlands often portray individual children with an ADHD classification as having a different, malfunctioning brain that necessitates medical intervention. This conceptualisation of ADHD might serve professional interests, but not necessarily the interests of children.

KW - adhd

KW - medicalisering

KW - beeldvorming

KW - leerboeken

KW - textbooks

KW - nederland

KW - rechten van het kind

KW - adhd

KW - children's rights

KW - medicalisation

KW - image building

KW - textbooks

KW - the netherlands

U2 - 10.1111/chso.12362

DO - 10.1111/chso.12362

M3 - Article

JO - Children & society

JF - Children & society

SN - 1099-0860

ER -